As the UK races toward its goal of achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2050, new research from Imperial College London provides crucial insights into how the country can maintain energy security while transitioning to a more sustainable energy system. This study dives into the delicate balance of ensuring that the UK’s future energy supply remains secure, affordable, and sustainable, while cutting down reliance on imported fuels like natural gas and biomass.
The Energy Trilemma: Affordability, Security, and Sustainability
At the heart of the research is the challenge known as the “energy trilemma”: the need to balance energy affordability, availability, and environmental sustainability. In the UK, natural gas plays a significant role in the energy mix, and securing stable, affordable sources of gas is key to keeping the lights on. But the UK also has ambitious climate goals, which require a dramatic reduction in carbon emissions by 2050.
Many critics argue that cutting down carbon emissions will compromise energy security or drive up costs. This study, however, shows that with the right policies, it’s possible to reduce fuel imports, increase renewable energy use, and promote energy security, all without drastically increasing overall system costs.
Key Findings: More Renewable Energy, Less Import Dependence
The study explored scenarios where the UK reduces its reliance on imported fuels by increasing the use of domestic renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar power. The researchers found that up to 50% of the maximum fuel import diversity can be achieved with only a 3% increase in system costs. This means that the UK can improve its energy security by diversifying fuel sources while still keeping the overall transition to net-zero affordable.
For example, a more diverse mix of energy imports could include a combination of cheap and clean fuels from reliable trading partners, alongside greater use of renewables and electrification of domestic heating systems. This would reduce the risk of relying too heavily on any one source of imported energy, making the system more resilient to price shocks or supply disruptions.
The Role of Heat Pumps and Electrification
One of the standout strategies identified in the research is the electrification of heating. Today, gas boilers are still widely used in UK homes, but by deploying heat pumps—which run on electricity and are far more energy-efficient—the UK could significantly reduce its dependence on imported gas. The transition to electric heating, powered by domestic renewable sources, will not only cut emissions but also promote energy security.
In fact, the research shows that a scenario where 50% of fuel imports are reduced could be achieved with around 34% higher costs. While this sounds steep, the study points out that improvements in the costs of renewable technologies (such as solar, wind, and energy storage) will likely offset much of this increase in the long run.
A Path Forward: Investing in Security and Sustainability
The most exciting takeaway from this study is that energy security and net-zero targets do not have to be in conflict. By strategically diversifying fuel imports and investing in domestic renewable energy, the UK can simultaneously reduce emissions and improve the stability of its energy supply.
This research highlights the importance of long-term planning and investment in clean energy technologies, which will make the energy transition both affordable and secure. For a sustainable future, ensuring that energy security and decarbonisation go hand in hand is key to achieving a stable, resilient, and low-carbon energy system for the UK.
Source
Energy import security in optimal decarbonization pathways for the UK energy system, Cell Report Sustainability, 2024-10-18
Boˆreal 